The Pacific was overall a good
miniseries but I feel as if the book just had more to offer. It went into
greater detail that the show couldn’t do. Here are 5 reasons why I feel like it
should have stayed a book.
1. Hugh Ambrose should have stayed the writer.
Hugh Ambrose wrote the book so he should have stayed the writer. What I
mean by this is; the miniseries had many script writers and I feel that has
affect the book because the script wasn’t written by Ambrose. Yes, it had his
oversight but he wasn’t directly directing it.
2. Keep
in the detail.
The book had a lot of detail that I feel the miniseries left out. Yes,
the miniseries was action packed and gave detail of the events and characters.
The book just had something different. It gave me a sense of what it was like
on the pacific side of the war.
3. Out with the visuals.
Whenever I picture The Pacific in
my head I always see the same people, James Badge Dale, Joe Mazzello, and Jon Seda
(the actors that played the characters). The miniseries gave me a visual that I
didn’t really like. Personally I like to use my imagination when it comes to picturing
characters in a book, I feel like the TV shows ruin that experience for me.
4. Script-writing.
I can’t think of one movie or show that stays exactly to the script. They
need to change something so it is more entertaining to the audience. I would
like for once something that stays true to the book. Follows every action and
word the characters say/do. It’s more fun to do it that way, sure it won’t be
as entertaining, but the fans of the book will compare it to the show and say, “Wow,
this is just like the book.” There would be as much criticism if it stayed to
the story line.
5. The book was amazing.
Have
you ever had one of those moment when you think that the books ending was so
good that they shouldn’t make another book because it will ruin the series?
This is a moment I had with the book. It was a fantastic book overall, but than
they had to make a show. They already had the icing on the cake so why put more
of it? They should have stopped at the book and not made a show because in my opinion
it just wasn’t as good.